Gatenby Law
  • Home
  • Our Firm
    • Our Team
    • Our Services
    • Media
    • Work with Us?
  • The Law
    • Drug Offences
    • Criminal Law
      • Assault Offences
      • Property Offences
      • Breach Offences
      • Dishonesty Offences
      • Prostitution Offences
      • Public Order Offences
      • Sexual Offences
      • OMCG and Serious Crime Offences
      • White Collar Offences
    • Traffic Offences
      • Dangerous Driving
      • Careless Driving
      • Disqualified Driving
      • Drink Driving
      • Drug Driving – Driving while relevant drug is present
      • Drug Driving – Drive under the influence of a drug
      • Speeding
      • Unlicensed Driving
      • Hooning Laws
      • Street Racing
    • Licence Applications
      • Work Licence Application
      • Removal of Licence Disqualification
      • Immediate Licence Suspension
      • Special Hardship Order
    • Domestic Violence
    • Police Interviews
    • Bail Applications
  • Contact Us
  • Resources
    • Guides
    • Publications
    • Queensland Police Stations – Contact Details
    • Criminal Convictions
      • Can I ask a Queensland Court for ‘no conviction recorded’?
      • Criminal Record, Recorded Convictions and your rights.
      • Disclosure of ‘no conviction recorded’
      • Applying for a Blue Card with a Criminal Conviction.
  • FAQ’S
    • Costs / Fees
    • Courts We Attend
  • GCL Blog
  • Pages
    • Pages

      • #4233 (no title)
      • 404
      • About
      • About Gatenby Lawyers
        • Michael Gatenby
        • Work with Us?
      • Alcohol interlock devices
      • Applying for a Blue Card with a Criminal Conviction.
      • Articles & Media
      • Ashleigh Smith
      • Breach of Bail
      • Bree Clarke
      • Brisbane Courts
      • Can I ask a Queensland Court for ‘no conviction recorded’?
      • Character Reference Guidelines – District Court
      • Character Reference Guidelines – Supreme Court
      • CHARACTER REFERENCE GUIDELINES- MAGISTRATES COURT
      • Community Based Orders
      • Community Service – Requirements of Order
      • Consorting – Relevant Offence Definitions
      • Contact Us
      • Contact Us
      • Contact Us / Criminal and Traffic Law Experts
        • Criminal Lawyers Gold Coast
      • Courts We Attend
      • Criminal Convictions
      • Criminal Law – Affray
      • Criminal Law – Aiding Suicide
      • Criminal Law – Assaults Occasioning Bodily Harm
      • Criminal Law – Common Assault
      • Criminal Law – Grievous Bodily Harm
      • Criminal Law – Malicious Acts
      • Criminal Law – Serious Assault
      • Criminal Law Services
        • Bail Applications
        • Criminal Law
          • Assault
          • Breach Offences
          • Dishonesty Offences
          • Property Offences
          • Prostitution Offences
          • Public Order Offences
          • Sexual Offences
          • White Collar Offences
        • Domestic Violence
        • Forms
        • Licence Applications
          • Immediate Licence Suspension
          • Removal of Licence Disqualification
          • Special Hardship Order
        • Police Interviews
        • Traffic Offences
          • Careless Driving
          • Dangerous Driving
          • Disqualified Driving
          • Drink Driving
          • Drug Driving – Drive under the influence of a drug
          • Drug Driving – Driving while relevant drug is present
          • Hooning Laws
          • Speeding
          • Street Racing
          • Unlicensed Driving
          • Work Licence Application
      • Criminal Record, Recorded Convictions and your rights.
      • Demi Quadrio
      • Disclosure of ‘no conviction recorded’
      • Dishonesty Offences – Bringing Stolen Goods into Queensland
      • Dishonesty Offences – Computer Hacking and Misuse
      • Dishonesty Offences – Dealing with Identification Information
      • Dishonesty Offences – Demanding Property with Menaces to Steal
      • Dishonesty Offences – Extortion
      • Dishonesty Offences – Fraud
      • Dishonesty Offences – Money Laundering
      • Dishonesty Offences – Petrol Drive Off
      • Dishonesty Offences – Possess Property Suspected of Being Tainted Property
      • Dishonesty Offences – Receiving Tainted Property
      • Dishonesty Offences – Robbery
      • Dishonesty Offences – Stealing
      • Dishonesty Offences – Stealing as a servant
      • Dishonesty Offences – Unauthorised Dealing with Shop Goods (UTAG)
      • Do I Need A Lawyer?
      • Drug Charges – Permitting Use of Place
      • Drug Charges – Possessing Dangerous Drugs
      • Drug Charges – Possessing Things
      • Drug Charges – Produce Dangerous Drugs
      • Drug Charges – Supplying Dangerous Drugs
      • Drug Charges – Trafficking in Dangerous Drugs
      • Drug Offences
      • EXPERT TRAFFIC LAW ADVICE – (07)55800 120
      • FAQ’S
        • Costs / Fees
        • Forms
      • Fixed Fees
      • Glossary
      • Guides
      • Home
      • Home Page
      • Legal Aid
      • Make an enquiry
      • Media
      • New Client
      • News
      • Offender Levy
      • OMCG and Serious Crime Offences
      • OMCG Laws – Contravene Order to Access Information
      • OMCG Laws – Contravene Public Safety Order
      • OMCG Laws – Contravening Restricted Premises Order
      • OMCG Laws – Habitually Consorting
      • OMCG Laws – Hindering Removal of Fortification Order
      • OMCG Laws – Recruiting person to become member of a criminal organisation
      • Our Firm
      • Our Offices
      • Our Services
      • Our Team
      • Patricija Nedeljko
      • Police Interviews
      • Police Stations We Attend
      • Possess Unregistered Firearms
      • Preparing For Your First Appointment?
      • PROBATION – REQUIREMENTS OF ORDER
      • Property Offences – Arson
      • Property Offences – Break and Enter
      • Property Offences – Burglary
      • Property Offences – Possess Implements of Housebreaking
      • Property Offences – Trespass
      • Property Offences – Unlawful Entry of a Dwelling
      • Property Offences – Unlawful Entry of Motor Vehicle
      • Property Offences – Unlawful Use of a Motor Vehicle
      • Property Offences – Wilful Damage
      • Publications
      • Qld Drug Offences
      • Qld Drug Offences Copy
      • Qld Weapons Offences
      • Queensland Police Stations – Contact Details
      • Services
      • Testimonials
      • Testimonials-01
      • Testimonials-02
      • Weapon Categories
      • What Court Will I Go To?
      • White Collar Offences – Corporate Fraud
Absolute Licence Removal
March 13, 2021

Removal of licence disqualification

M. T. Gatenby Case Notes, Penalties, Traffic

In Murray v Commissioner of Police [2021] QDC 48, the Court was required to consider whether the Applicant had demonstrated that it was appropriate to remove an absolute licence disqualification imposed for an offence of Dangerous Operation of a Motor Vehicle.

FACTS

On Christmas Day 2016, the applicant had been drinking heavily during the course of the day. At about 4.30pm that day, it was decided that he and others would go to another address in Springwood. The applicant ordered an Uber driver for one of his companions, but drove himself.

He drove a distance of about five kilometres. He was approaching the intersection of Jardine Drive and Rholanda Crescent at Springwood. At the same time the deceased child was walking with his older brother and family friends southwards along the western concrete footpath of Rholanda Crescent. 

The applicant approached the intersection at high speed, did not slow down nor apply his brakes. He lost control of his car, crossed the north and south bound lanes of Rholanda Crescent, crashing and ultimately killed a child. He was drink driving with a BAC of 0.162%

At the time of sentence in the Beenleigh District Court the Applicant was 25 years and had a limited criminal history and an excellent work history.  His traffic history included speeding offences and the accumulation of demerit points.  He had completed a traffic offenders program.

On 18 December 2017, he entered a plea of guilty in the Beenleigh District Court to an offence of dangerous operation of a motor vehicle causing death (while affected by an intoxicating substance).  He was sentenced to seven years imprisonment with parole eligibility after two years. The Applicant was disqualified absolutely from holding a driver licence.

BASIS OF APPLICATION

The Applicant had served two years and two months before being granted parole. He was subject to strict conditions, including that he must not consume any alcohol.

The building company he used to work for was prepared to rehire if he was able to obtain a driver licence. A job with the building company would require him to have a valid driver licence because he would be required to drive to construction sites, sometimes up to four different sites on any given day, and to drive to suppliers to collect materials, tools and equipment. 

DECSION

His Honour, Judge Chowdhury DCJ dismissed the Application.

PRINCIPLE

His Honour had regard to the desirability for a person to engage in meaningful employment. 

Long periods of disqualification from driving may prove a very severe handicap to man when he comes out of prison and desires to pursue a different type of life to that which has led him into that prison. Such periods of disqualification may shut out a large sector of employment, especially in certain areas. 

R v Shirley [1969] 1 WLR 1357 per Sachs LJ

The court balanced the above against the need for the disqualification to be an actual penalty as discussed in Silvo v Commissioner of Police.

a driver licence disqualification can hardly be considered a punishment for a prisoner during the period of incarceration.” 

Slivo v Commissioner of Police [2016] QDC 46, per Judge FARR, DCJ at [41]

Ultimately, the court found that a judgement is required which balances the interests of the applicant in having his or her licence restored with those of the community in not prematurely sanctioning the right of an offender to resume driving after committing a serious criminal offence which placed in jeopardy the safety of members of that community.

In all the circumstances Judge Chowdhury was not satisfied that the applicant has met his onus in establishing that the absolute disqualification should be removed at this point.  His Honour suggested that minimum period of 12 months in the community was required. The Beenleigh District Court did not set aside the absolute licence disqualification.

Disclaimer

This website contains general information about legal matters.  The information is not advice, and should not be treated as such.  You must not rely on the information on this website as an alternative to legal advice from your lawyer or other professional legal services provider. This publication is for your information and interest only. You should never delay seeking legal advice, disregard legal advice, or commence or discontinue any legal action because of information on this website.

The receipt of any information from us in this publication is not intended to create nor does it create a solicitor-client relationship between you and Gatenby Criminal Lawyers Pty Ltd.

For specific legal advice you should immediately contact Gatenby Criminal Lawyers on (07) 5580 0120.

Case Note – When disability is not a mitigatory factor. NEW DEPUTY CHIEF FOR QLD’s MAGISTRATE COURT

Related Posts

Case Notes

Case Notes

Legal professional privilege

Case Notes

Case Notes

Case Note Update- Pre-sentence custody declaration.

Case Notes

Case Notes, Comparative Sentences, Penalties

Case Note – Parole Delay on Sentences.

Contact Details

Office: (07) 5580 0120
Fax: (07) 5580 0952
Michael Gatenby: 0457 999 022

Demi Quadrio: 0477 800 620
Ashleigh Smith: 0477 800 421
Patricija Nedjelko: 0477 800 880

Gatenby Law
Copyright © 2019 Gatenby Criminal Lawyers, All Rights Reserved

News

  • Case NotesLegal professional privilege
  • New Supreme Court Judges Appointed.
  • Case NotesCase Note Update- Pre-sentence custody declaration.

Southport

Suite 6, Level 2
Excalibur House
52 Davenport St
Southport Qld 4215

Coomera

Suite 3, East Wing
Fortune Place
2 Fortune Street
Coomera Qld 4209

Postal

PO Box 1672
Southport BC 4215