Gatenby Law
  • Home
  • Our Firm
    • Our Team
    • Our Services
    • Media
    • Work with Us?
  • The Law
    • Drug Offences
    • Criminal Law
      • Assault Offences
      • Property Offences
      • Breach Offences
      • Dishonesty Offences
      • Prostitution Offences
      • Public Order Offences
      • Sexual Offences
      • OMCG and Serious Crime Offences
      • White Collar Offences
    • Traffic Offences
      • Dangerous Driving
      • Careless Driving
      • Disqualified Driving
      • Drink Driving
      • Drug Driving – Driving while relevant drug is present
      • Drug Driving – Drive under the influence of a drug
      • Speeding
      • Unlicensed Driving
      • Hooning Laws
      • Street Racing
    • Licence Applications
      • Work Licence Application
      • Removal of Licence Disqualification
      • Immediate Licence Suspension
      • Special Hardship Order
    • Domestic Violence
    • Police Interviews
    • Bail Applications
  • Contact Us
  • Resources
    • Guides
    • Publications
    • Queensland Police Stations – Contact Details
    • Criminal Convictions
      • Can I ask a Queensland Court for ‘no conviction recorded’?
      • Criminal Record, Recorded Convictions and your rights.
      • Disclosure of ‘no conviction recorded’
      • Applying for a Blue Card with a Criminal Conviction.
  • FAQ’S
    • Costs / Fees
    • Courts We Attend
  • GCL Blog
  • Pages
    • Pages

      • #4233 (no title)
      • 404
      • About
      • About Gatenby Lawyers
        • Michael Gatenby
        • Work with Us?
      • Alcohol interlock devices
      • Applying for a Blue Card with a Criminal Conviction.
      • Articles & Media
      • Ashleigh Smith
      • Breach of Bail
      • Bree Clarke
      • Brisbane Courts
      • Can I ask a Queensland Court for ‘no conviction recorded’?
      • Character Reference Guidelines – District Court
      • Character Reference Guidelines – Supreme Court
      • CHARACTER REFERENCE GUIDELINES- MAGISTRATES COURT
      • Community Based Orders
      • Community Service – Requirements of Order
      • Consorting – Relevant Offence Definitions
      • Contact Us
      • Contact Us
      • Contact Us / Criminal and Traffic Law Experts
        • Criminal Lawyers Gold Coast
      • Courts We Attend
      • Criminal Convictions
      • Criminal Law – Affray
      • Criminal Law – Aiding Suicide
      • Criminal Law – Assaults Occasioning Bodily Harm
      • Criminal Law – Common Assault
      • Criminal Law – Grievous Bodily Harm
      • Criminal Law – Malicious Acts
      • Criminal Law – Serious Assault
      • Criminal Law Services
        • Bail Applications
        • Criminal Law
          • Assault
          • Breach Offences
          • Dishonesty Offences
          • Property Offences
          • Prostitution Offences
          • Public Order Offences
          • Sexual Offences
          • White Collar Offences
        • Domestic Violence
        • Forms
        • Licence Applications
          • Immediate Licence Suspension
          • Removal of Licence Disqualification
          • Special Hardship Order
        • Police Interviews
        • Traffic Offences
          • Careless Driving
          • Dangerous Driving
          • Disqualified Driving
          • Drink Driving
          • Drug Driving – Drive under the influence of a drug
          • Drug Driving – Driving while relevant drug is present
          • Hooning Laws
          • Speeding
          • Street Racing
          • Unlicensed Driving
          • Work Licence Application
      • Criminal Record, Recorded Convictions and your rights.
      • Demi Quadrio
      • Disclosure of ‘no conviction recorded’
      • Dishonesty Offences – Bringing Stolen Goods into Queensland
      • Dishonesty Offences – Computer Hacking and Misuse
      • Dishonesty Offences – Dealing with Identification Information
      • Dishonesty Offences – Demanding Property with Menaces to Steal
      • Dishonesty Offences – Extortion
      • Dishonesty Offences – Fraud
      • Dishonesty Offences – Money Laundering
      • Dishonesty Offences – Petrol Drive Off
      • Dishonesty Offences – Possess Property Suspected of Being Tainted Property
      • Dishonesty Offences – Receiving Tainted Property
      • Dishonesty Offences – Robbery
      • Dishonesty Offences – Stealing
      • Dishonesty Offences – Stealing as a servant
      • Dishonesty Offences – Unauthorised Dealing with Shop Goods (UTAG)
      • Do I Need A Lawyer?
      • Drug Charges – Permitting Use of Place
      • Drug Charges – Possessing Dangerous Drugs
      • Drug Charges – Possessing Things
      • Drug Charges – Produce Dangerous Drugs
      • Drug Charges – Supplying Dangerous Drugs
      • Drug Charges – Trafficking in Dangerous Drugs
      • Drug Offences
      • EXPERT TRAFFIC LAW ADVICE – (07)55800 120
      • FAQ’S
        • Costs / Fees
        • Forms
      • Fixed Fees
      • Glossary
      • Guides
      • Home
      • Home Page
      • Legal Aid
      • Make an enquiry
      • Media
      • New Client
      • News
      • Offender Levy
      • OMCG and Serious Crime Offences
      • OMCG Laws – Contravene Order to Access Information
      • OMCG Laws – Contravene Public Safety Order
      • OMCG Laws – Contravening Restricted Premises Order
      • OMCG Laws – Habitually Consorting
      • OMCG Laws – Hindering Removal of Fortification Order
      • OMCG Laws – Recruiting person to become member of a criminal organisation
      • Our Firm
      • Our Offices
      • Our Services
      • Our Team
      • Patricija Nedeljko
      • Police Interviews
      • Police Stations We Attend
      • Possess Unregistered Firearms
      • Preparing For Your First Appointment?
      • PROBATION – REQUIREMENTS OF ORDER
      • Property Offences – Arson
      • Property Offences – Break and Enter
      • Property Offences – Burglary
      • Property Offences – Possess Implements of Housebreaking
      • Property Offences – Trespass
      • Property Offences – Unlawful Entry of a Dwelling
      • Property Offences – Unlawful Entry of Motor Vehicle
      • Property Offences – Unlawful Use of a Motor Vehicle
      • Property Offences – Wilful Damage
      • Publications
      • Qld Drug Offences
      • Qld Drug Offences Copy
      • Qld Weapons Offences
      • Queensland Police Stations – Contact Details
      • Services
      • Testimonials
      • Testimonials-01
      • Testimonials-02
      • Weapon Categories
      • What Court Will I Go To?
      • White Collar Offences – Corporate Fraud
Grievous Bodily Harm
January 21, 2021

Attorney General successfully appeals GBH sentence .

M. T. Gatenby Comparative Sentences, Domestic Violence, Penalties Court of Appeal, GBH, Grievous Bodily Harm

On Tuesday 19 January 2021, the Queensland Court of Appeal upheld an Attorney’s Appeal against a sentence of two and half years with an immediate parole release for a 26 year old man charged with Grievous Bodily Harm. In upholding the Appeal the Court has signified that even for young offenders with limited history and good prospects of rehabilitation a deterrent sentence is called for GBH charges.

Justice Boddice, with whom Justices Morrison and Henry agreed, allowed the appeal and set aside the original sentence to the extent that Mr Chitty’s parole release was effectively fixed after 8 months.

Sentencing of relatively young offenders generally gives rise to the importance of considerations of rehabilitation. However, for some time Courts have recognised and stressed the importance of deterrence, both general and personal, in the sentencing of young men for serious acts of public violence upon innocent members of the community.

Justice Boddice R v Chitty; Ex parte Attorney General (Qld) [2021] QCA 2

Antecedents:

Chitty was aged 26 at sentence and 25 at the time of the commission of the offence. He had a criminal history containing one entry. This was an 11 February 2013, conviction in the District Court of Brisbane for an offence of affray. He was sentenced to 12 months probation and 120 hours community service. No conviction was recorded.

The sentencing Judge accepted that the respondent had had dysfunction in his upbringing. He had a promising sporting career cut short by injury. He was by all accounts, a highly valued and respected employee. At the time of sentence Chitty was in the midst of a relationship breakup, and had responsibility for the care of his children.

He had been operating under the challenges of unmedicated and untreated medical conditions. These fitted the criteria of:

  1. major depressive disorder;
  2. generalised anxiety; and
  3. panic disorder.

The respondent had been receiving psychological treatment. He showed good prospects of rehabilitation.

GBH Offence:

The offence of grievous bodily harm (GBH) was committed on 6 August 2019. The complainant, a 39 year old male, had been drinking with friends at a venue in Cairns earlier that evening. The respondent had also been drinking.

Shortly after 11 pm, the respondent and his friend entered a McDonald’s restaurant and purchased food.  There was some conversation between the men and words were exchanged. The incident was captured on CCTV and it appeared that there was an invitation to ‘step outside’.

As the respondent opened the door, the complainant turned towards the respondent’s friend. The camera footage depicted the respondent take two steps back towards the complainant and punch the complainant once in the face.

The complainant fell to the ground, striking the back of his head. He lay motionless. The respondent turned to open the door and left the store with his friend. The respondent made no effort to assist the complainant lying on the

The Complainant, a pilot, suffered facial injuries and a broken jaw, which required surgery.

GBH sentence at first instance

The sentencing Judge accepted the comparable decisions provided some guidance that GBH charges would ordinarily attract a period of imprisonment. The respondent’s offending was distinguished as it did not involve gratuitous street violence, nor was it an assault on emergency services officers. The respondent also had good prospects of rehabilitation. Whilst he had a past criminal history, that occurred when he was 18 years of age and in circumstances where it may well be that his mental health had some aspects of similarity.

Sentencing Principles

The Court of Appeal in R v Chitty; Ex parte Attorney-General (Qld) [2021] QCA 2 accepted that this was not a case of gratuitous street violence, but the violence could instead be described as disproportionate.

The consequences to the Complainant were quite significant. His injuries included:

  1. a broken jaw in three places, necessitating surgery;
  2. repair to his teeth.
  3. ongoing vestibular dysfunction,
  4. regular headaches; and
  5. vertigo.

These conditions materially affected his career as a professional airline captain. His loss of income and medical expenses were said to amount to in excess of $140,000.

It is the extent of that damage which is the principle justification for the sentence imposed below. One could perhaps defend a legal system in which the particular consequences for the victim of such a blow are treated as of little significance and the court is required to focus solely on the circumstances of the blow itself. But that is not our system; for reasons which are evident enough, the offender will find that his punishment may depend on the extent of the damage the victim happens to sustain. That is, the risk that a blow which might by good luck have caused little damage in fact has catastrophic results, as it had here, is one which is shared by the victim and the offender.

Per Pincus J, R v Amituanai (1995) 78 A Crim R 588 at 589

The need for deterrence, both general and personal, was particularly warranted having regard to the respondent’s prior conviction, which related to a single punch (although charged as an affray).

The offending conduct constituting the GBH and the consequences may have justified a head sentence significantly higher than two and a half years’ imprisonment, however it was accepted that the head sentence fell within a proper exercise of the sentencing discretion.

Principle

The Court of Appeal has affirmed the position that in all but unusual circumstances actual periods of imprisonment are applicable. This applies even where it is a single punch from a youthful offender.

Disclaimer

This website contains general information about legal matters.  The information is not advice, and should not be treated as such.  You must not rely on the information on this website as an alternative to legal advice from your lawyer or other professional legal services provider. This publication is for your information and interest only. You should never delay seeking legal advice, disregard legal advice, or commence or discontinue any legal action because of information on this website.

The receipt of any information from us in this publication is not intended to create nor does it create a solicitor-client relationship between you and Gatenby Criminal Lawyers Pty Ltd.

For specific legal advice you should immediately contact Gatenby Criminal Lawyers on (07) 5580 0120.

Liability limited by a scheme approved under professional standards legislation.

New Gel Blaster Laws for Queensland Technology at Southport Court

Related Posts

Case Notes

Case Notes, Comparative Sentences, Penalties

Case Note – Parole Delay on Sentences.

Case Notes

Case Notes, Penalties

Case Note – Impact of Parole Delay on Sentences.

Penalties and Sentences Act Qld

Penalties

Penalty Unit Increase

Contact Details

Office: (07) 5580 0120
Fax: (07) 5580 0952
Michael Gatenby: 0457 999 022

Demi Quadrio: 0477 800 620
Ashleigh Smith: 0477 800 421
Patricija Nedjelko: 0477 800 880

Gatenby Law
Copyright © 2019 Gatenby Criminal Lawyers, All Rights Reserved

News

  • Case NotesLegal professional privilege
  • New Supreme Court Judges Appointed.
  • Case NotesCase Note Update- Pre-sentence custody declaration.

Southport

Suite 6, Level 2
Excalibur House
52 Davenport St
Southport Qld 4215

Coomera

Suite 3, East Wing
Fortune Place
2 Fortune Street
Coomera Qld 4209

Postal

PO Box 1672
Southport BC 4215